Here’s a excellent report from Cheryl. Cheryl and husband Doug were on the Barbados Bus trip in November. They live in Michigan. They recently returned from a 7 day cruise on the Norwegian Dream
Cheryl,
Hope you had a wonderful trip.
Tell me, how did the Norwegian Dream compare with the Sun Princesss? Service, cabins, food, etc. I have been holding off until I heard from you. May I post your observations on my blog?
Waiting to hear
Tim 
Tim
Here ya go:
My observations of the Norwegian Dream.
Since our Sun Princess cruise was just 2 months ago and still fresh in my mind, many of the observations are in comparisons to that boat, fair or not.
While the Dream is an ok ship, the Sun Princess and other ships we have been on were nicer in some minor or subtle ways:
The layout of the Dream is very "odd". This ship was lengthened a few years back and that affects the layout. For instance, one of the dining rooms is in the middle of the ship, Deck 9. Our room was on the very front of the ship, Deck 9. To get from the middle or back section of Deck 9 to our room, we had to either go up or down one floor to get around the dining room, or go through it. Most people go through it. Kinda odd to be parading around in your pool attire while people are trying to enjoy lunch.
The buffet was the biggest aggravation. The Sports Bar IS the buffet. There is only seating for around 150 people in the area (with several TVs, which is what makes it the Sports Bar). Not nearly big enough for a boat that holds 1700 passengers. On days we were arriving in port at 7 or 8 AM, most people preferred the buffet to a more time-consuming breakfast in the restaurant, so the buffet lines were long with A LOT of people standing around waiting for a table to open up. You can take your food to tables outside, but 2 mornings it was either too windy or rainy to enjoy eating outside. I saw 2 teenage girls eating on the steps by the elevators one morning. It was a disaster!
On personal note, another major inconvenience to having the buffet in the Sports Bar: we sailed on the day of the 2 football playoff games. They broadcast the first game in the Sports Bar and in the staterooms, even though Fox is not one of the normally carried channels. However, the second game which featured Indianapolis (where my sister-in-law lives) was not broadcast at all. She was not a happy camper, and she wasn't alone. There were A LOT of really pissed off people. Our assumption is they didn't want the sports fans taking up all the tables in the buffet area for three hours right in the middle of dinner time.
Another of the little things that was disappointing about this ship -- the buffets (main one, BBQ on deck, etc) didn't have trays. It is difficult to carry a plate of food, silverware and napkin, dessert, and glass or 2 of beverages without a tray. Not a big deal, but a bit of an annoyance to have to fight the traffic at the buffets to go back 2 or 3 times to get everything you want. I honestly don't remember if all of other ships have had trays or not. I know the Sun did.
Glasses on the buffet were smaller (8oz) like most other ships so you almost always needed more than one for a meal. On the Sun, they were a little larger which I thought was a nice feature.
Food was good and very compatible to Princess. We have sailed with Norwegian 3 other times and all 4 times the food was good. Not gourmet, but I didn't think Princess or Carnival was any better or any worse. All were what we expect for the category of cruising that these lines fall in. If I want gourmet food, I will sail on Crystal. The Italian Trattoria (specialty restaurant without an additional charge) was particularly good. We ate there twice.
We did have to wait at least 30 minutes for the main dining rooms at least twice when we arrived to eat at 7:30 or 8:00 at the main dining rooms. On contrast, we found we were seated immediately if we went anytime before 7, but there was a rush later. Unfortunately they don't provide "flashing beepers" for the waiting crowd, so you couldn't wander too far from the entrance or you risked missing your name being called. Other passengers I talked to that have been on Norwegian's bigger, newer ships say they have more restaurants and choices so the wait at the main restaurants is not a problem. This boat had 2 main dining rooms, the buffet, the Italian restaurant, and one additional-charge French restaurant. So basically only 5 restaurant choices, where the new ships have 8 or 10, I heard. The serving time in all the restaurants was comparable with other lines we have been on -- 60- 90 minutes for dinner. In spite of the wait times, we much prefer the open seating system to an assigned time, though I think Princess hit the jackpot by making both options available to its passengers.
Stateroom was very similar to the room we had on the Princess and other boats (inside standard cabin). Shower was smaller than some, but I don't recall which lines have the larger showers.
Condition of the ship was excellent. While it doesn't have the grand, multi-story atrium like many other ships, thus it doesn't have the "grandiose" feel, it was still very clean, modern, well maintained.
Staff was very personable and knowledgeable, other than when faced with "why aren't you showing the Indy / New England playoff game" question from 100 passengers. They refused to even acknowledge that they had just showen the first game. The reception desk staff kept INSISTING that if the game was on Fox, we didn't see it because they don't get Fox. It was kind of humorous -- "You mean that game we just watched -- you didn't broadcast it?" "No, we don't broadcast Fox" "then what did we just watch?" "I don't know but it wasn't Fox". This went on for about 10 minutes. Kinda like watching a hamster on a wheel....
While who the captain of a ship is doesn't matter one iota to me, I do have to say that this one (don't remember his name) was a real kick. His daily announcements and speeches at the various occasions were very entertaining. The guy had a real sense of humor and personable demeanor -- not at all as formal or stand-offish as some captains can be. Really a nice guy.
Overall, there were things with this boat we didn't like as well, but if the price were right, we would sail on it again. As I said, this was our 4th Norwegian cruise and we have been happy with all of them. As a reference, we have been on 3 Carnival (last one was 1999, so it has been awhile), 4 Norwegian, 1 Princess, and 1 Costa (Mediterranean). All of them have had their pluses and minuses, but we would sail any of them again. I think more has to do with the ship itself than the line. While the Sun Princess and the Dream are similar in size, the Sun is just laid out in a much nicer manner. In ratings, the Princess and Costa are our two favorite cruises, but in each case the people we met and ports of call are what made the difference more than the boat itself. Obviously, the newer the boat, the better the design is going to be as they learn what works as years go by, and can design to match new design "styles" like freestyle. But given the opportunity, I would probably get on just about any ship to sail with folks we had a good history with. Friends can make a trip on a mediocre ship one of your best vacations while a brand new ship can get boring after a week if there is no one to share the fun with or the rest of the passengers are all over 80 (we did one of those, once, too).
Hope this info helps you (yes, you can post it to your blog). Sorry if I got too long winded (family has always said I talk to much -- guess it carries over to my typing, too ).
If you (or anyone else) has anything else I can answer, fire away.
Happy February!
Cheryl